Best Things to Do in Cherry Grove, Fire Island

Whether you’ve arrived by the Sayville Ferry or hopped on a Fire Island Water Taxi, Cherry Grove welcomes you with its vibrant energy, unique charm, and iconic LGBTQ+ history. Just a short 10-minute water taxi ride from Pines Point, this lively Fire Island destination is packed with fantastic restaurants, nightlife, and local gems worth exploring.

Where to Eat in Cherry Grove, Fire Island

Breakfast at Floyd’s

Start your day at Floyd’s, the only place in Cherry Grove where you can grab coffee or breakfast before 10 AM. This cozy, local favorite fills up fast in the summer, so calling ahead for reservations is a good idea.

Lunch with a View at Island Breeze

For a midday meal with stunning waterfront scenery, Island Breeze is the perfect spot. Their outdoor deck overlooks the Great South Bay, offering a prime location for a breezy, laid-back lunch. Whether you’re craving a classic burger or a fresh seafood dish, this spot never disappoints.

Sunset Dining at Top of the Bay

For dinner with a view, head to Top of the Bay, where you’ll find elevated takes on classic dishes alongside breathtaking sunset views over the bay. If you’re visiting during peak season, be sure to book a reservation.

Classic New York–Style Pizza at Cherry Grove Pizza

Craving a slice? Cherry Grove Pizza serves up giant New York–style pies alongside hearty pasta dishes. Whether you want a quick bite between beach trips or a relaxed dinner, this spot is a must-visit.

Sweet Treats at Sweet Licks

No beach day is complete without ice cream! Sweet Licks offers a variety of flavors, perfect for cooling off on a warm summer afternoon.

Walk to the Beach & Experience the Ocean

No visit to Cherry Grove is complete without a walk to the beach. Stroll down the boardwalk and step onto the soft white sand as you take in the expansive Atlantic Ocean views. Whether you're soaking up the sun, swimming in the refreshing waves, or just enjoying a quiet moment by the shore, the beach is the heart of Cherry Grove. Fire Island’s untouched coastline and car-free environment make it the perfect place to truly unwind and embrace nature.

Shopping & Exploring the Boardwalks

Take a leisurely stroll along Cherry Grove’s boardwalks, where you’ll find an eclectic mix of unique homes, art installations, and colorful decorations that capture the spirit of the community. For a bit of shopping, stop by The FIG Store, which sells Fire Island–themed clothing and souvenirs, or explore the general store near the Ice Palace, where you can find everything from beach essentials to fun novelty items.

If you’re looking for a truly oceanfront dining experience, The Sandcastle is one of just two beachfront restaurants on all of Fire Island. Operating since the 1950s, this historic spot is a great place to soak in uninterrupted ocean views while enjoying a cocktail or fresh seafood dish.

Visit the Plant Nursery in Cherry Grove

The Plant Nursery in Cherry Grove offers a rotating selection of trees, shrubs, perennials, and grasses, along with organic potting soil, compost, and fertilizers used by professionals. You’ll also find fresh-cut flower bouquets every weekend, perfect for brightening up your Fire Island stay.

Nightlife & Entertainment in Cherry Grove

Drag Shows & Dance Parties at the Ice Palace

For a wild night out, The Ice Palace is the place to be. This legendary venue hosts high-energy drag shows, dance parties, and themed events all summer long.

Drinks & Ferry Views at Cherry’s

Before heading back to Pines Point, grab a fruity cocktail at Cherry’s on the Bay, a lively outdoor bar with a direct view of the ferry dock—so you’ll know exactly when it’s time to sail back to the mainland.

Getting to Cherry Grove from Pines Point

If you’re staying at Pines Point in Fire Island Pines, Cherry Grove is just a short walk away. You can take a scenic stroll through the community boardwalks, or if you’re looking for a quicker option, the Fire Island Water Taxi gets you there in less than 10 minutes.

Plan Your Perfect Cherry Grove Getaway

Cherry Grove is a one-of-a-kind destination that blends beachside relaxation, great food, and legendary nightlife. Whether you’re exploring for the day or making a weekend out of it, you’ll find plenty of ways to soak up the unique energy of this historic Fire Island community.

And if you’re looking for the perfect place to stay, Pines Point in Fire Island Pines offers the ideal getaway—just minutes from all the action while giving you the space to relax and unwind.